Stories
StoryTrack record

Grading our own calls, honestly

Our live calls are flat so far: 28 of 72 up. The backtest did better. Here's why Forecast is changing.

Tradewind Forecast · Monday, November 16, 2026 · 2 min read

We publish every call we make and keep it up whether it works or not. So here is where things stand, measured the strict way: each call on the exact copy and printing it named, from its price that day to its fair value now.

Live calls (October 31 to now): 72 measured, 28 up, and the middle call is flat at -0%. The backtest (our method run over October 5 to November 2 with only each day's data): 143 calls, 94 up (66%), middle call +8%. For comparison, 57% of all Near Mint English cards worth $5 or more rose over the same two-week windows.

28/72
Live calls up
94/143
Backtest calls up
57%
Every $5+ card, same windows

Why we measure on one copy

A card's headline value is its best Near Mint copy, and that can jump when a dearer printing gets its first sale. Measured that way, our Aggron call from Triumphant looked like a double. On the copy we actually called, it's +7%. Every number Forecast shows now is the strict one.

What's changing

Five calls a day was too many to be worth your attention, and a call without the reasoning behind it doesn't teach you anything. So Forecast now leads with the read: what moved this week and why, the stories behind the runs, and the patterns underneath them, taught with real cards. Calls stay, fewer of them, as cards to watch, and they include warnings like a reprint about to land.

The best live call so far, for the record:

Every card shows the value we quoted on the day we wrote about it, and Tradewind's fair value for the same copy today.

Forecast is research, not financial advice. Card prices can fall as easily as they rise; past calls do not promise future ones. Every price is Tradewind's fair value from real sales, never a listing.

More stories