Magic: The Gathering · Modern Horizons 3

Chthonian Nightmare

R · 83 · Foil · TCGplayer

Fair value · NM

$1.10

52.8%past 90 days

Fair value · NM
$1.10
Change · 90d
−24%

The line is fair value over time, from sales only, ending at today's. Bubbles group sales that sold close together, sized by how many: solid ones count toward fair value, hollow ones were left out. Round marks are raw copies, square ones slabs. The strip along the bottom counts sales.

30-day outlook · NM

Forecast

See where it lands in 30 days, how sure Tradewind is, and why.

Sign in to unlock

Recent sales

Yesterday$1.47

Sat$1.11

Wed$0.94

How fast it sells

~2 days

NM at fair value · ~3 sales a week · 108 listed

Population

—

No graded copies counted yet

In play

Commander

in 1% of top decks

01

Every condition

What a Foil copy is worth in each condition, from its own sales. Pick a row to switch the page to it.

02

Sales

Every Foil sale in one place, raw and graded, newest first, with what the buyer paid including shipping. Narrow it by condition, grader or grade. Times are US Central.

10 counted · most sold $1.11 – $1.47

Sun, Nov 151 sale

  • 11:45 PM

    NMOnline · Buy it now

    $1.47

    free ship

Sat, Nov 141 sale

  • 9:07 PM

    NMOnline · Buy it now

    $1.11

    free ship

Wed, Nov 111 sale

  • 1:17 AM

    NMOnline · Buy it now

    $0.94

    free ship

Mon, Nov 92 sales

  • 12:41 AM

    NMOnline · Buy it now

    $0.98

    free ship

  • 12:30 AM

    NMOnline · Buy it now

    $1.14

    free ship

Thu, Nov 51 sale

  • 9:48 AM

    NMOnline · Buy it now

    $1.47

    free ship

Fri, Oct 301 sale

  • 7:58 PM

    NMOnline · Buy it now

    $1.12

    free ship

Mon, Oct 261 sale

  • 1:40 PM

    NMOnline · Buy it now

    $2.27

    incl. $1.49 ship

Sun, Oct 251 sale

  • 5:52 PM

    NMOnline · Buy it now×2

    $1.47

    free ship

Fri, Oct 231 sale

  • 4:35 AM

    NMOnline · Buy it now

    $1.47

    free ship

10 sales · that's every one

Showing the latest 20 of 24 Foil sales.

Every sale, its price, shipping and how it sold — on any paid plan.

Sign inSee all 24 Collector plan

03

Play

Where the card is legal, and how much competitive play it sees.

Formats

  • StandardNot legal
  • PioneerNot legal
  • ModernLegal
  • LegacyLegal
  • VintageLegal
  • PauperNot legal
  • CommanderLegal

For every printing of this card, from Scryfall.

Competitive play

Share of top-placing tournament decks that play this card (every printing counts), last 90 days. Bigger events, better finishes and newer decks count more. Constructed: MTGO and Melee results via the MTGO Decklist Cache. cEDH: EDHTop16 with data from TopDeck.gg. Commander: EDHREC. See the meta

FormatTierDecksCopiesTop 8sTrend
CommanderCPlayed in its niche (0.5–2%)1.3%(71,580)———
cEDHFSeen, but rarely (under 0.5%)0.4%(47)1.019—
ModernFSeen, but rarely (under 0.5%)0.2%(54)1.52—
VintageFSeen, but rarely (under 0.5%)0.2%(3)1.00—
LegacyFSeen, but rarely (under 0.5%)0.0%(1)1.00—

04

Details

Game
Magic: The Gathering
Set
Modern Horizons 3 (MH3)
Number
83
Rarity
R
Type
Single
Released
Jun 14, 2024
SubType
Enchantment
OracleText
When Chthonian Nightmare enters the battlefield, you get EEE (three energy counters). Pay X E, Sacrifice a creature, Return Cthonian Nightmare to its owner's hand: Return target creature card with mana value X from your graveyard to the battlefield. Activate only as a sorcery.

Pull odds

Open a pack
  • FoilR · Modern Horizons 3 - Collector Booster Pack1 in 90 packs1.11%
  • NormalRare or mythic rare, including Booster Fun, double-faced, and retro frame cards: R · Modern Horizons 3 - Play Booster Pack1 in 69 packs1.44%

05

Other printings of Chthonian Nightmare