Promethean Princess, Bestower of Flames (Quarter Century Secret Rare)
PHNI · PHNI-EN052
Quarter Century Secret Rare
10 printings
Nightmare Wheel
PGD · PGD-106
Ultra Rare
14 printings
Kaito, Bane of Nightmares
PPDSK · 220
M
6 printings
Gemini Elf
LON · LON-000
Secret Rare
12 printings
Nightmare Lash
MRD · 219
R
Chthonian Nightmare (Borderless)
MH3 · 330
4 printings
The Last Warrior from Another Planet
LON · LON-077
Ashiok, Nightmare Weaver
THS · 188
Enigmaster Packbit
PHNI · PHNI-EN042
3 printings
Magicians of Bonds and Unity (Quarter Century Secret Rare)
PHNI · PHNI-EN000
Reaper on the Nightmare
DR1 · DR1-EN026
Rare
2 printings
Spiritualism
LON · LON-094
5 printings
Ashiok, Nightmare Muse
THB · 208
The Masked Beast
LON · LON-001
9 printings
The Black Goat Laughs (Quarter Century Secret Rare)
PHNI · PHNI-EN078
Recurring Nightmare - 1998 Brian Selden (EXO)
WCD
S
Destiny Board
LON · LON-088
8 printings
Ashiok, Nightmare Muse (Borderless)
THB · 256
Saffira, Dragon Queen of the Voiceless Voice (Quarter Century Secret Rare)
PHNI · PHNI-EN020
Raidraptor - Rising Rebellion Falcon
PHNI · PHNI-EN045
Nightmare Apprentice (Quarter Century Secret Rare)
LEDE · LEDE-EN029
Nightmare Apprentice
MP25 · MP25-EN004
Starlight Rare
Revival Jam
LON · LON-006
Super Rare
Silent Magician LV4
NTR · NTR-EN001